Chinese Drywall Insurance Coverage Update: A Tale of Two Pollution Exclusions

On March 2, Auto-Owners Insurance Company dropped its Eleventh Circuit appeal of a Middle District of Florida decision granting summary judgment to its policyholder on defense and indemnity coverage for Chinese drywall liabilities.  The district court’s opinion, authored by Judge Susan Bucklew in Tampa, denied Auto-Owners’ summary judgment motion seeking to avoid coverage obligations based on the pollution …

11th Circuit Unsure If Insurance Policy Ambiguities Are Automatically Construed Against Insurers In Florida

Let’s take a short break from the top 10 insurance myths series to discuss a recent Eleventh Circuit decision that might seem a bit puzzling at first.  (Hat tip to my friend Dan Thomas, construction lawyer extraordinaire at Leopold Law, for sending me a copy of the opinion.)  In Ruderman v. Washington National Insurance Corp., …

Myth #2: Policy Forms Are “Standard” And Cannot Be Negotiated

Let’s start with a little background.  Since the McCarran-Ferguson Act  was passed by Congress in 1945, the insurance industry largely has been exempt from federal regulation.  That includes (with some limited exceptions) federal antitrust law.  So things that most companies cannot do (for example, all major banks agreeing to offer the same paltry interest rates …

Myth #1: Your Business Is “Fully Covered”

Last week I provided a list of my top 10 commercial insurance myths and misconceptions.  Today I want to start with the first misconception on the list: Your Business Is “Fully Covered”. I hear this a lot from clients.  From a liability standpoint, it usually means their company has a comprehensive general liability (CGL) policy …

Top 10 Commercial Insurance Myths & Misconceptions

Commercial insurance is complicated, and decisions regarding what insurance to buy and whether to assert or pursue an insurance claim frequently are based on false assumptions about what risks are covered.  Below is a list of 10 of the most common misconceptions regarding commercial liability insurance.  In the coming days, I will examine each of …

Beware Oceanside 932: Failure to Produce Insurance Policies Puts Defendant in Default

This is for the insurance defense lawyers out there, and the plaintiffs’ lawyers who love to make their lives miserable. One of my loyal readers in Jacksonville (my friend and former partner at Gunster, construction law guru Ed Whelan) sent me a copy of this January 5, 2012 order in a construction defect case in …